Two halves and two overtimes were not enough to settle the Horizon League quarterfinals on Tuesday afternoon, and after eight rounds of penalty kicks Butler defeated Valparaiso 5-4 in the shootout at Eastgate Field after the two sides played to a 2-2 draw through 110 minutes. 

Kristen Manski (Saint Charles, Ill./North H.S.) saved Butler’s first kick in the shootout while Valpo made its first three tries.  Tied at three after the Bulldogs’ fourth attempt, Butler’s Julie Burton made a stop of the Crusaders’ fourth attempt.  Both keepers saved the fifth attempts and the shootout went to sudden death.

For more information visit valpoathletics.com.

---

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Girls Academy Playoffs: Under-19 Standouts

2026 Women's MAAC Breakout Candidates

2026 Men's MAAC Breakout Candidates